"It's a built-in convenience to the system, based on the goodwill that people will re-load their card," said Goodwin.Īccording to Goodwin, Streetsblog's inquiry represented the first time an "enterprising journalist blew the lid off this" (actually, Stanley Roberts at KRON appears to be first). MTC spokesperson John Goodwin acknowledged that Clipper cards can "go negative," which he said the MTC programmed into the card to help customers get out of a transit system where there aren't fare machines or customer service personnel to help them add value to their cards. MTC settles its Clipper debts every day with the transit agencies participating in the program, so BART would have been repaid the cost of my trips from regional funds allocated to the Clipper roll-out. Of course, someone has to pay for the scam and that would be the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC), the regional transportation planning body that administers Clipper (though in the end it's the taxpayer who foots their bill). At a cost of $2 per card to manufacture, I'm essentially paying for the privilege of adding two pretty blue cards to the landfill. If I had entered BART at one of the terminus stations, like Pittsburgh Bay Point, and traveled to SFO round-trip, I could have gamed BART for $21.80.īecause the cards still register the negative balance, and I would have to pay that down before I could add a positive balance to the card upon re-loading it, the smart thing to do would be to throw away the cards. When I tagged out at the International Terminal fare gates, instead of an "Insufficient Fare" warning, which I would have seen had I been using a $2 traditional BART fare card, my Clipper card subtracted $6.10, leaving me with a balance of $3.90 of someone else's money.Īfter completing my return trip to Civic Center with my other $2 Clipper card, I ended up with $16.20 worth of BART rides for $4. I rode to SFO, a trip that should have cost me $8.10. When I tagged into the system at the fare gate, the card had a $2 value. I bought two $2 cards at the vending machine, paying $4 in cash. Let's take Civic Center to the San Francisco Airport, a trip I made over the weekend to see if the scam worked as a Streetsblog tipster had suggested. Then ride BART where ever you desire and you will never have to pay more than $2. Pay cash and do it at a Muni Metro vending machine in downtown San Francisco if you really don't want to be traceable. Buy a bunch of them this way, if you like.
At any retailer or vending machine that sells Clipper, load the minimum $2 dollars on a new Clipper card. Here's how the scam works, and mind you it is especially effective on BART, where you don't have fare inspectors or conductors to check your Clipper card and catch you. Or maybe you did and you hoped to fly under the radar? And you probably didn't realize it's set up with the perverse economic incentive to game the system, whereby you can scam distance-based fare operators like BART out of most of the cost of your trip. Of all the ways you can use your Clipper smart card for payment on transit agencies throughout the Bay Area, you probably didn't realize you could use it like a credit card, spending up to $10 more than the value on the card.
0 kommentar(er)
